Reviewed base3f42f3c8981a8a0795812d10f29bc270c0fb5b9b through77e43c71/fd4f32cb/f687abadd. Both complete reports and actual terminal artifacts read. Exactly two reviewers, one fresh Sol T3 task and one actual Pi CLI run. Each applied all M1/2/3/5 plus test audit/thermo. Source remains unchanged; no old review credit is claimed for a future fix.
- Sol warning1, also Pi premortem3, two model families. Valid accented filenames overflow the output component after timestamp or collision suffix. Sol actual native probes show source239bytes first run0/second1, only one upload, source intact; source242bytes dryrun0/real1. Fix only file result-name construction, preserving timestamp, normal stems and full source path in metadata, with a UTF8 byte budget reserving the existing helper's maximum -999 suffix. Extend existing real-transport frozen-clock pipeline coverage with both long-name boundaries. No generic naming/Zoom/YouTube/transport rewrite
- Pi warning1 primary, one family, now independently reproduced. On Python3.12.14, ordinary missing-path control exits2 with run-file help, unknown ~user exits1 with generic RuntimeError/debug rerun, symlink loop exits1 likewise. No secret or HTTP boundary reached. Catch RuntimeError alongside OSError within the new file validation and add controlled invalid-path cases. The first default-runtime probe also found unknown-user1 but loop2; the explicitly pinned3.12 parity receipt resolves that version-dependent difference. Keep both receipts, claim only the runtime actually observed
- Pi nit4 test weakness, one family. The invalid-input guard currently runs only with --dry-run, so it cannot detect a regression that moves real preflight ahead of validation. Remove --dry-run in this existing negative test, keep key/network guards, and assert the leading run-file error rather than --path only in its fix. The [500] success-test name is cosmetic and is not itself an ActOn
- Sol nit2/Pi nit6 module summary, two families, direct docs consequence. Include local audio in the authored module summary and regenerate. Add a short README naming consequence for necessary long-stem shortening and preserved complete metadata source path
- Pi nit5, one family. Add exactly the run-file row to the existing test_contract.py COMMANDS help inventory and mirror. It protects existing help alias/examples/exit-code behavior for the new command; no new suite, registry or selector. This supporting file needs explicit ownership extension. Existing live strict verifier already reads file help, so this is a narrow completeness improvement, not proof of a current user-visible failure
- Pi nit6 prompt wording, one family. The bundled prompts now apply to local files as well as YouTube. Drop the YouTube-only wording in the existing parser prompt help and SKILL.md prompt sentence if included in the authorized docs consequence. Extra root/run examples are optional and not needed
- Pi warning1 secondary unreadable-source/os.access suggestion. Defer. Acceptance requires missing/directory/empty errors before upload; actual open failures already occur before HTTP sends and keep source intact. An os.access precheck cannot establish later readability or macOS permission behavior and adds no requested guarantee. No new readability/consent gate
- Pi nit2 dead file defaults/normalization branch. Noted, keep. These follow the neighboring Namespace normalization and cause no observed defect; changing generic dispatch is outside the minimal repair
- Pi nit3 three --no-update insertions. Noted, keep. All actual variants are tested, and the current change matches explicit scope. A hypothetical fourth variant does not justify a refactor of already reviewed flag construction
- Pi nit4 pipeline test name. Noted, keep unless edited naturally for the new boundary parameters. Behavior is clear from HTTP status parameter; no additional test needed merely for naming
- Pi nit7 README concision/doctor placement. Noted, optional style deferred. The current claims are accurate. A run-file help line in the existing Checks examples can be included with direct docs consequences, without broader cleanup. Do not add a consent gate or paid E2E run; current controlling brief explicitly skips them
- Pi nit8 file example --no-summary. Noted. It matches the transcript-only re-listening use case and current acceptance. General invocation must still honor a user's summary request. No source defect reproduced; sample cleanup is optional
- Pi nit9 verifier docs 'both sources'. Defer broad verifier-doc wording outside the authorized single interface row. Those features still actually drive YouTube/Zoom. No verifier feature/paid-eval expansion
-465 cause-first means removing the stale-version paragraph before each attempt's real ERROR. Keep existing labeled browser-then-anonymous order; one real malformed-ID failure fulfills the requested safe receipt. The argv regression failed before the fix and Sol read the installed pinned warning-suppression branch. No second paid/tool failure replay needed -471 requires private child HOME regressions and preserved100-column formatter, which the final tests exercise. A whole-suite fresh HOME/uv-cache check was not required by the current narrow brief; do not mutate global HOME or broaden the test -M4A/audio-mp4 is the explicit transport criterion. Real acceptance of other codecs remains NOT RUN, not silently passed, and creates no new paid check
Story452 only: authoring/andy/transcript/scripts/transcript.py, scripts/tests/test_cli.py, scripts/tests/test_transcript.py, README.md, direct SKILL.md prompt wording only if authorized, and supporting scripts/tests/test_contract.py one inventory row only if authorized; corresponding generated mirrors via compile then remote. No manual generated edits. No catalog/count delta expected. No peer scripts/check.py/test_check.py/checks.md changes. No465/471 own diff changes, other than required restack heads.
Rebase fixes into452, restack existing native stack, read actual PR state before every push. Focused transcript check, proportionate plain check and each changed exact-head just signoff. Head explicitly decides the changed-code review coverage and any necessary new-head Mini proof. The original pair, full reports, immutable packet and original Mini proof stay pinned to f687aba; no automatic paid review or old-pair coverage claim.
Pi actual process0, final provider=openrouter, model=anthropic/claude-opus-5.5, stopReason=stop, both emitted thinking fields xhigh, settled abortedfalse, no tool-error markers. Duration919.124756seconds,72turns,99read-onlytoolcalls, one CLI run. Two non-selected claude-code pattern warnings retained; no fallback. Sol task completed/result_available, zero pending child runs; actual T3 terminal untruncated,16focused passing dots and native repro commands retained. Sol579.125seconds from actual requested/complete run timestamps is not asserted here until separately derived.
No effective-provider-internal effort claim. Paid Deepgram, private interviews, native skill eval and CI/release NOT RUN per brief. Mini original proof passes with cleanup and two shell startup warnings; fleet convergence remains separately unconfirmed at prior3f42 deployment. No source edits have begun.