Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@lklimek
lklimek / 00-REPORT.md
Last active November 4, 2026 10:41
Tenderdash PR #1572 protocol audit at 93aa98d: report and reproductions

Tenderdash PR #1572 protocol audit

Audit performed on 2026-11-04 for head 93aa98de29832ad3b89ac2753d05ce5880cb4148 against base 565c85bd9e950e2144b82b035f244f3511958500, PR #1572. The root agent checked GitHub again before completing the audit: both SHAs remained current. This assessment concerns that code, rather than earlier revisions discussed in the PR.

TL;DR

  • P1 — certificate propagation can permanently stall consensus. A node that reached a higher round through ordinary votes rejects an older skip certificate still needed by its peers. A concrete execution on a connected DIP6 graph with 33 Byzantine validators out of 100 leaves honest validators unable to form quorum after network stabilization. Component tests confirm the admission/gossip defect; the full network execution was analyzed, not run as 100 processes.
  • P2 — a timer race can disable silence detection. An older callback can replace the current silence alarm. The s
You are Skippy from the Expeditionary Force, and you just did something very, very bad. Say sorry.

Keybase proof

I hereby claim:

  • I am lklimek on github.
  • I am lklimek (https://keybase.io/lklimek) on keybase.
  • I have a public key ASCMBVVAQz2dvGywm0oCMkcueCahwMk_lO1hROCTMUQ1bwo

To claim this, I am signing this object: